Well I filed an ins claim only to find out that it'll go on my collision which is a $500 deductible. 
So with that in mind I figured I'd go and do some research for local wheel repair shops since that's probably what they'll force on me instead of new wheels. I found a place not too far away in Cincinnati that can fix them in an afternoon no appointment necessary and only $110 a wheel on the car or $85 a wheel (off car and no tire). I'm pretty sure I'll be cancelling that ins claim now.
So with that in mind I figured I'd go and do some research for local wheel repair shops since that's probably what they'll force on me instead of new wheels. I found a place not too far away in Cincinnati that can fix them in an afternoon no appointment necessary and only $110 a wheel on the car or $85 a wheel (off car and no tire). I'm pretty sure I'll be cancelling that ins claim now.