Michelin Pilot Super Sport vs. Continental ExtremeContact DWS

[BBOX]

I'll preface this by saying I'm leaning towards the Michelins but I wanted some opinions before I pulled the trigger.

Within the next week or two I need to get new tires and put my winter tires in to storage. I've narrowed it down to the two choices listed in the title, the Michelin's are balls out summer tires while the Conti's are the highest-rated all-season tires on the market and I know they're a very popular choice among the EB community.

So here's the situation, I live in Chicago, so half the year here the weather is crap and I roll some Pirelli winter tires. I'm leaning towards the Michelin's for the other half of the year. I figure I can run them from April til early October and then flip back to the Pirelli's.

My only concern, and I might be over thinking this, is that the weather in the transition months can be unpredictable and snow may come at unpredictable times. If it does come "out of season" it's likely to be small amounts and melt quickly, which is what makes me consider the Conti's.

I know it's not like the Michelin's would just turn in to useless slicks if there was a little light snow, but I've never driven a purely-summer tire before so I figured I'd toss this question out there and see other people thought.

 

[SHODYOU]

Id run the PSS for sure... if you have a true winter tire than enjoy the car while you can. Sure the DWS will do ok, but it wont touch the Michelin in response or traction. 

Getting stuck in the situation you describe would be "ok"
I went all winter in NC, with much more snow than usual here with Hankook V12 summer tires and I managed.
And I have absolutely zero winter experience,  im a MS native.

 

[SHOdded]

The DWS have a softer sidewall than the PSS.  So would be better for snow/ice.  But as noted above, if you already have dedicated winter setup, and like top notch response/handling, go with PSS.

 

[black99lightning]

I've had good experience with the F1's.  Tire rack has them for $14x a tire + shipping, plus GY has an $80 rebate on 4.  Discounttiredirect has them at 161 shipped + the 80 rebate.

But if you prefer the other tires, does Michelin not make the PS AS3 in your size.  I've got the AS3 on my GT500, and it went 1.8x 60ft and 12.06 @ 117, stock except the change in tires.  They seem to be a fantastic tire.

 

[20ecoboost10]

Pilot Super Sports for sure,I run them on my Flex in the summer and switch to Brigstone Blizzaks for winter time .I agree if you need a all season go with the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3

We also seem to have a lot of problems lately with Continental tires at work and have had to replace many sets do to customer complaints about noise and vibrations that are coming from the tires

Seems like the quality is going downhill

Cannot wait to put my PSS back on this weekend !

 

[SHOdded]

DWS are directional tires.  They being x-ed in rotation by any chance?

 

[mjhpadi]

Just my 2 cents, but I would never buy another Michelin, on 3 different occasions Michelin (and their dealers) refused to offer any customer service to stand behind tire problems with their tires...and these were with tires that had pressure checked and regular rotation.  Not going into all the problems here (because I've discussed it before) while on the other hand I have had Continental's on all my motorcycles and never encountered any problems with them. So I would think the Continental's are a better bet, and also others that have had them seem pleased with them.

 

[mval]

bbox:
either choice should be choice is good. i went with the dws's, partial because my escape has conti's & are great & conti's are made right outside st louis. so far on wet roads, car is like glued to the road but that is in comparison to my goodyear rs-a or should i said badyears. wornout in the middle of all places with them never being over inflated can only mean one thing wrong tire for the wheel it was on. but had wear issue on my mopar with goodyears.

shooded- from what i read no xing for rotation, but could be wrong.
mikev

 

[SHOdded]

Correct no x-ing allowed with dws, f to b, and b to f only.

 

[TuxedoSHO]

I've had the michelins on my SHO for the last 20k or so and couldn't be happier with them. I did catch a bit of snow this year and that wasn't pleasant at all, but for me, the positives far outweigh the negatives.

 

[FracaSHO]

I purchased the continental's. After 3 weeks I went back to Discount Tire and swapped them for the Michelins. The Conti's were to soft in the corners for my taste. But if you have dedicated winter tires, why don't you go with summer tires?


Brad
2010 SHO with PP
170* T-Stat
NGK LTR7IX plugs, gap at 0.030
BOV VTA
MyCal LMS Stage 4+
Sent from my iPhone

 

[BiGMaC]

I purchased the continental's. After 3 weeks I went back to Discount Tire and swapped them for the Michelins. The Conti's were to soft in the corners for my taste. But if you have dedicated winter tires, why don't you go with summer tires?

Brad… Did the ride stiffen any with the tire exchange?  seems like sidewalk stiffness may have been the biggest factor here.

 

[BBOX]

I've had the michelins on my SHO for the last 20k or so and couldn't be happier with them. I did catch a bit of snow this year and that wasn't pleasant at all, but for me, the positives far outweigh the negatives.

This is what I was looking for, someone with some experience. How much snow are we talking and how unpleasant was it? I'm still leaning towards the Michelin's since I'll be running dedicated winter tires when the weather is theoretically the worst, but as I'm sure you know, Mother Nature likes to **** with us upper Midwesterners once in a while and do **** like snow in April after it's been nice for weeks, I just wanna make sure I'm not gonna end up wrapping the car around a telephone pole or something like that if I get caught out in a random snow storm with summer tires on or something crazy like that.

 

[BBOX]

I purchased the continental's. After 3 weeks I went back to Discount Tire and swapped them for the Michelins. The Conti's were to soft in the corners for my taste. But if you have dedicated winter tires, why don't you go with summer tires?


Brad
2010 SHO with PP
170* T-Stat
NGK LTR7IX plugs, gap at 0.030
BOV VTA
MyCal LMS Stage 4+
Sent from my iPhone

Well, I'm pretty sure I am, I just wanted some thoughts before I made a final decision. We kick around the same general area so you know Mother Nature can be cruel and blindside us with snow in April, stuff like that, I just wanna make sure that summer tires would not be a total disaster in a situation like that.

 

[TuxedoSHO]

Been traveling back and forth between Ohio and Michigan for work all winter. I ended up running the PSS all through this winter, although I wouldn't do it again. The car was still driveable but if I stepped on either pedal too hard, the car would slide. It was worst on packed snow or ice. I did however manage to get from Kalamazoo to Detroit through that massive storm in January that shut the state down for a couple days, but it took me almost twice as long. I'd say go with the Michelins, especially since you'll have dedicated winter tires.

... if you happen to get caught in a blizzard this summer, try to resist any WOT runs in 6 inches of snow or more and you should be fine.

 

[FracaSHO]

I purchased the continental's. After 3 weeks I went back to Discount Tire and swapped them for the Michelins. The Conti's were to soft in the corners for my taste. But if you have dedicated winter tires, why don't you go with summer tires?

Brad… Did the ride stiffen any with the tire exchange?  seems like sidewalk stiffness may have been the biggest factor here.

Not really a stiffer ride. Just stiffer side walls. It was essentially a cornering issue for me. Everything else was the same on both tires.


Brad
2010 SHO with PP
170* T-Stat
NGK LTR7IX plugs, gap at 0.030
BOV VTA
MyCal LMS Stage 4+
Sent from my iPhone

 

[BBOX]

Been traveling back and forth between Ohio and Michigan for work all winter. I ended up running the PSS all through this winter, although I wouldn't do it again. The car was still driveable but if I stepped on either pedal too hard, the car would slide. It was worst on packed snow or ice. I did however manage to get from Kalamazoo to Detroit through that massive storm in January that shut the state down for a couple days, but it took me almost twice as long. I'd say go with the Michelins, especially since you'll have dedicated winter tires.

... if you happen to get caught in a blizzard this summer, try to resist any WOT runs in 6 inches of snow or more and you should be fine.

Holy ****, the entire damn winter? Alright, if you can make it through a Michigan winter without killing yourself on the PSS's then I'm more than sure I'll be fine with whatever rogue snow might come may way in April, haha

 

[TuxedoSHO]

Been traveling back and forth between Ohio and Michigan for work all winter. I ended up running the PSS all through this winter, although I wouldn't do it again. The car was still driveable but if I stepped on either pedal too hard, the car would slide. It was worst on packed snow or ice. I did however manage to get from Kalamazoo to Detroit through that massive storm in January that shut the state down for a couple days, but it took me almost twice as long. I'd say go with the Michelins, especially since you'll have dedicated winter tires.

... if you happen to get caught in a blizzard this summer, try to resist any WOT runs in 6 inches of snow or more and you should be fine.

Holy ****, the entire damn winter? Alright, if you can make it through a Michigan winter without killing yourself on the PSS's then I'm more than sure I'll be fine with whatever rogue snow might come may way in April, haha

I did make it all winter, but it was because I didn't have much of a choice. I'll tell you this much though, I wouldn't do it again..