Weathertech or Husky

[BlueSHO]

Which floor liners do you guys prefer? Are the weathertechs worth the extra money? Anyway thanks for any suggestions..

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[FoMoCoSHO]

If I had to do it again, I'd probably try the Huskys.

Look to be high quality and all of the Weathertech badges have fallen off mine.

Unacceptable at that price point IMO.

 

[BiGMaC]

I only have a trunk liner. It is WeatherTech and I have had no problems in 2+ years.  I have an extra set of SHO mats that I rotate, but I don't have to deal with the salt and chemicals in Phx.

 

[BlueSHO]

Yeah we get terrible weather here in Illinois

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[cror1]

I have the weathertech, and quality is decent. They are hard and do not fold when cold, maybe just a little. I have heard from other people that husky are  soft and therefore fold easily when it gets really Cold..

 

[SHOw-Me State]

I have the Weathertechs and have been happy, although I do wish they covered the section between the foot well and the front of the seat. I'm 6'5" and with the seat all the way back, that section is exposed.  No different than the factory mats in that regard.

Also, one of my emblems/stickers fell off too.  I contacted McNeil and the sent new emblems/stickers free of charge.  I did buy direct from them though.

 

[BlueSHO]

Yeah looks like either one is ok.

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[JagerBomb]

I'm on my 4th vehicle and I've only ever used the WeatherTech mats. I like them and the quality is there. The stickers on them will fall off. Its gets so hot inside the car here in florida is just going to happen. But the cool thing is, is that there is a guy on my Jeep forum that makes new gel dome stickers to replace the weatherTechs. So when they fall off, I'll get something new. WeatherTech for the win.

 

[glock-coma]

I have the weathertech, and quality is decent. They are hard and do not fold when cold, maybe just a little. I have heard from other people that husky are  soft and therefore fold easily when it gets really Cold..

hit the nail on the head. These are the husky liners.
Just noticed this on the back seat floor liner before cleaning.

There's no amount of bending it back that will fix it. The husky are not as flexible. The fronts a still ok but I don't think there's any saving the rear.

 

[Blackhawk]

I went with husky mostly because I am a cheap ass.  My only complaint is the gap between the front seat and the mat but that is a problem with the WeatherTechs as well as Show-Me mentioned above.

 

[BlueSHO]

What I'm liking about the Huskys in the front is that they seem to cover the carpet better at the threshold where you go in and out of the car compared to the weather techs.

Passenger side

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[Blackhawk]

That was another reason I went with the Huskys

What I'm liking about the Huskys in the front is that they seem to cover the carpet better at the threshold where you go in and out of the car compared to the weather techs.

Passenger side

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[Beaster1174]

I went with the husky liner. From photos it looks like the huskys have better coverage, including the dead pedal, which is where my left foot lives most of the time.

 

[Ryan02Stang]

Another vote for Husky!

 

[Skylane95]

I bought the Weathertech because I had them on other cars( BMW, VW, Honda). Not a great fit on the SHO. The passenger side slides around, and both sides leave large unprotected areas near the sills. A waste of money.

 

[BlueSHO]

The large unprotected areas mainly at the threshold with the weathertechs is a main reason I went with the Huskies

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[Joleat]

I went with Huskies for a few reasons:

1 - Price
2 - I bought a vehicle with Huskies once and I remembered how easy they were to clean (This may be a moot point, but I do not have any experience with WeatherTech. However, based on how they appear in photos, they seem to have a rough texture. If that is the case, it seems like they might be harder to clean.)
3 - This may be a moot point as well since I haven't seen MKS/Taurus WeatherTechs in person, but in many pictures, WeatherTech seems to punch a hole in the mat where the carpet "hook" is. Husky, on the other hand, molds the hook shape into the mat so there is no chance slush can seep through.


Shameless plug: I have a full set (front, rear, and trunk) of black Huskies listed in the for sale section. I no longer have my MKS.