I ended up going with The Hartford. Surprisingly, had I elected to purchase the same coverage as I had with Erie, it was going to be a few dollars cheaper. Instead, I decided to bulk up my coverage. I now have at least double the coverage in every category and I increased medical payments from $5,000 to $100,000. It was only an extra couple dollars a month. I also picked up the maximum rental and towing coverage. I had no rental or towing through Erie. In the end, I'm paying about $175 more per year than I was with Erie, but the increased coverage is more than worth it. Once we bundle our homeowner's insurance, the car insurance will drop almost enough to cover the additional $175. The homeowner's policy will also receive up to a 15% discount. Overall, I'm extremely pleased with the decision.
I just hope I can continue my streak of luck and not have to file any claims.
I just hope I can continue my streak of luck and not have to file any claims.