Turn on / off pop with JBL MS8 and Sony

I'll take better pictures of my connectors. I have both the 2011 and 2013 wiring diagrams. They are different. The 2011 says there is a separate amp to drive the subs in the rear deck. The 2013 says that all the speakers including the sub's are driven off the Sony amp / DSP.

My car for some reason or another has an undocumented change where all the speakers are driven off the Sony amp. There is no separate amp for the subs.

My car has the same wire colors as the 2013 but the pin out is different.

I've got another MS8 on the way just in case I got a bad one.

I really appreciate your help and patience in helping me solve this issue.
 
themetalmaster said:
I'll take better pictures of my connectors. I have both the 2011 and 2013 wiring diagrams. They are different. The 2011 says there is a separate amp to drive the subs in the rear deck. The 2013 says that all the speakers including the sub's are driven off the Sony amp / DSP.

My car for some reason or another has an undocumented change where all the speakers are driven off the Sony amp. There is no separate amp for the subs.

My car has the same wire colors as the 2013 but the pin out is different.

I've got another MS8 on the way just in case I got a bad one.

I really appreciate your help and patience in helping me solve this issue.

That's just crazy that it is wired differently.  Something's up, and we need to get to the bottom of it.  I strongly feel that the MS8 is just fine.  When they go bad, they go really, really bad.  Like all-hell-breaks-loose bad, and you'll know it.  It also happens extremely rarely, and seems to be directly tied into a possible very low voltage situation when doing tuning, so I doubt you'll run into that.  Point is, I think the MS8 is not the issue. 

For now, I would advise attaching a simple toggle switch to act as your turn-on.  Use a constant 12V, and we'll troubleshoot with the MS8 this way.  I would also order up a PAC TR-4, and get ready to install it.  It only costs a few bucks and always could be good to have one around.  Now, I would make sure that all speaker inputs and outputs are really what they are supposed to be, and later we can pour over manuals to make sure.  Then, I would leave alone any remote turn on leads from any part of the system.  Use a switch, and test with the MS8 completely off to make sure no pops are coming.  Then turn on the MS8 after the whole system powers up.  Then the other way.  I did a build for a new Flex, and we had a pop when trying to use a certain turn on point.  We resorted to using the TR-4 on a CAN signal line.  No pop, but the MS8 does power up sometimes when something like a door is opened, or some other CAN signal occurs.  It was supposed to only be the CAN Multimedia BUS, but apparently it wakes up more than we thought.  That said...NO pops occur on his Flex. 

For MY Flex, my new 2013... I purposely wired the MS8's turn on directly to the ignition switch ON.  I did this because I was having difficulty with turn on signals and mind you, I installed this a year ago before we knew much about the 2013's vast differences from the one I had before.. That said, the ignition ON is a great place to connect, but I get a turn on pop if I switch to ON, let the system start playing, and then try to start the car.  The slight interruption of power when the car tries to start screws it up a bit, and I get a pop.  So what I do is when I have the car in the ON position but not running (let's say, while filling with gas), when I get back in I'll move the key quickly to off, and then right back to Start and ON.  This tiny change means that there's no pop, the MS8 is happy, the amps are happy, and everything works perfectly.  It also means that my MS8 turns off in ACC mode, which for me is a good thing because I'll drain my batt quickly with the system playing, so ACC could be just to open a window or run the NAV, or something like that.  I could fix this with a TR4 but honestly, I'm so used to turning the key off and right back on when I need to (like filling with gas while listening out the window), that it just has become automatic.  I am explaining this BTW because it may suit you and your build too.
 
themetalmaster said:
Ok, I tried what Dalum suggested and interrupted the violet wire on pin 3 so that the side coming from the car is going to remote in on the MS8 and the remote out of the MS8 is going to the same wire on the connector of the sony amp. I still get the speaker pop.
Like below:

CAR-----remote in MS8 ---- remote out MS8 --- Sony amp

If I don't connect the remote out in this configuration and the wire on pin 3 is interrupted, the Sony amp never turns on as I don't hear any music. But I still get speaker pop when I shut the car off. If I do connect the remote out, the Sony amp powers on and I hear music, and also speaker pop when I shut the car off or turn it on.

So now I'm thinking I have a bad MS8.

The MS8 has a constant (battery) +12v lead right?  I want you to disconnect the turn on input and turn on output wires from it (sony totally off with no turn on going to it).  Turn the car totally off with all the doors closed but windows open.  Now use a test lead and bridge the +12v and turn on input. Listen for a pop (guessing none).  Now disconnect that jumper wire and listen for another pop (guessing pop).  That would prove its a problem in the MS8.

Repete the test with the sony connected to the MS8 turn on output and the highest delay setting.  You will probably get a pop at the time of the delay when the sony turns on and a pop when the ms8 turns off.

You won't be able to do anything about the Sony popping its outputs when powered on but I'm really surprised the MS8 doesn't mute its input for a second or 2 when it powers on.  With a properly working MS8 you may find yo won't get the turn on pop either.  If you still do you'll need a delay timer turning on the ms8 after the sony powers up so it won't amplify its pop to the speakers.

Using 2 diodes you can isolate the factory and ms8 turn on from each other but still use them both at the same time.  This will turn on the sony first from the car, ms8 on after its added on timer delay turn on, then keep the sony via the ms8's turn on output until after ms8's amp is off.
 
I'd almost bet my highly modified Flex that it isn't the MS8.  If the car was with me and I got to actually see everything, I would absolutely bet my own car that the MS8 is not at fault here.  Like I said, when it goes wrong, it goes really, really wrong. 

It DOES mute outputs.  My system, it goes on with the ON ignition, head unit kicks on first, MS8 boots up (but isn't playing output), amps turn on, MS8 un-mutes and the system plays beautifully.
 
Nobody wants a Flex without turbos
:rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2: :rofl2:
:blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah: :blah:
 
themetalmaster said:
Dalum and Lanson, really appreciate your help with this.

I will try out both of your suggestions and report back.

We pretty much suggested the same things.  The difference is he's in love with the MS8 and wants to give me his car  :gathering: while I'm trying to rule out the MS8.  Its not looking good for it from what you already said (only turn off thump without sony amp powered on at all and both thumps with sony powered).  One of the only other things I could think besides turn on sequence would be a bad ground somewhere and one device is pulling a better ground through the audio interconnects (sony speakers out).
 
dalum said:
themetalmaster said:
Dalum and Lanson, really appreciate your help with this.

I will try out both of your suggestions and report back.

We pretty much suggested the same things.  The difference is he's in love with the MS8 and wants to give me his car  :gathering: while I'm trying to rule out the MS8.  Its not looking good for it from what you already said (only turn off thump without sony amp powered on at all and both thumps with sony powered).  One of the only other things I could think besides turn on sequence would be a bad ground somewhere and one device is pulling a better ground through the audio interconnects (sony speakers out).

Its a lot more likely a wire is not doing what we're thinking it should be doing. 
 
Big update. I fixed it. I had it wired 100% correct, but the fact that the amplifier is CANBUS controlled meant that I couldn't control it with any amount of relays or timer circuits. I read about a similar case where a gentleman with a Lexus IS350 had the exact same problem, I used his solution to fix it.

I used a Cache Audio COE8EQ as a line output converter to send low level signal to the MS8 instead of using the high level inputs. The conversion from high level inputs to low level keeps any power on/off pops from the Sony amp from being passed through to the MS8. So it works perfect now, sounds great too.

I just need to build a better mounting bracket for my gear. The good news is that I am free to upgrade the rest of the system whenever I get the time and motivation.

So the system is set up like this,  Nav Headunit --->Sony AMP ---> COE8EQ ---> MS8 ---> Speakers

Its possible that there was a simpler way to do this, but this is the solution that I got to work.
 
I'm definitely happy you got it to work!  I think maybe a PAC TR4 turn-on circuit would the easier way, but no harm done here the other way, as long as the noise floor is not audibly worse.

Well done man! 

Now...we'll have to figure out why your car's setup is "special" and not in the wiring manual.  But maybe later, you got tunes at least.
 
Lanson said:
I'm definitely happy you got it to work!  I think maybe a PAC TR4 turn-on circuit would the easier way, but no harm done here the other way, as long as the noise floor is not audibly worse.

Well done man! 

Now...we'll have to figure out why your car's setup is "special" and not in the wiring manual.  But maybe later, you got tunes at least.

The TR 4 made the turn on pop not as bad. But the turn off pop was still there. The factory amp doesn't care if voltage is on the turn on lead once it's booted up, it uses a digital can signal to power down. I guess this is so Bluetooth and navigation voice will still work if you have the radio off.

I have the gains on the Cache box set to the minimum. When volume on the HU is at about 7/8 the way up the output voltage on the cache box is around 2.8, which is the maximum the MS8 can take on the line level input side. When configured as such the MS8 reports OK for signal level. It sounds the same as before to my ears, without the possibly speaker damaging pops.

It might be a dumb and expensive solution, but it worked for me.
 
I installed my first MS8 a couple days ago in my 2016 Explorer Sport. I ran into this issue for turn on/off as well. Hope it helps someone -

The Infamous MS8 Pop and how to solve it -

Several documented examples of it here (and there are many more):
Turn on / off pop with JBL MS8 and Sony
http://www.diymobileaudio.com/forum/technical-advanced-car-audio-discussion/101151-ms-8-loud-pop.html
http://www.diymobileaudio.com/forum/technical-advanced-car-audio-discussion/162123-jbl-ms8-turn-off-pop-does-not-do-while-muted.html

First, I'd like to thank DanMc85 for his excellent post below which was the ultimate solution:
Variable Line Level Preamp Outputs From ACM (Factory Radio) For Amplifier Upgrades

To quote from his post:
Amp Remote Turn On:  ACM (Harness B) - Violet/Red (Pin 18)    OR  ACM (Harness A) - Brown (Pin 7)
        Note these remote turn on wires are NOT 12 volts (approx 6 volts)... some amplifiers may require a 12 volt remote input and may need to convert this output with a third party device or relay. While you have the dash apart, you could also tap the accessory power wire at the key ignition harness for a guaranteed 12 volt wire for remote turn on. Also some sound processors, such as the JBL MS-8, support 4 Volts and higher as a remote turn on voltage so this is not an issue if you are using one.

UPDATE:
      Better remote turn on wire option for Push to Start Vehicles:
      Connector C3501 - Pin 5 - Brown/Yellow (22 Gauge) - 12 Volt w/ Delayed Accessory Feature
          - This wire is going into the 150 Watt AC/DC Power Inverter

I have bolded and enlarged the section relevant to the solution. First I used the ACM audio enable wire for remote trigger for the MS8 and that was what was causing the pop. The MS8 and subsequently all of my amps were staying on for minutes beyond the the car shutoff. Just before the internals of the APIM/ACM would go offline I'd get the pop then the AMP/MS8 would shutoff.  Moving the remote turn-on to the C3501 connector worked like a charm and shuts down the MS8 as soon as I power off the car or system. Much better and thank you DanMc85!

The Pop IS NOT coming from the MS8. It was coming from the ACM as it was shutting down. I'm assuming ACM doesn't do a soft shutoff and line level amp capacitors were draining causing the pop before going offline. (what it sounds like to me anyway)

Hope this helps someone. If you dont have an ACM or aren't coming from the Ford Factory System, replace ACM with "Head Unit" and it will be relevant to you. Essentially the head unit is shutting down releasing energy into the RCA's before the MS8 is turning off the Amps. This is the problem you need to solve to eliminate the MS8 Pop.

I have a build log for my 2016 Explorer Sport started here if interested -
http://www.diymobileaudio.com/forum/build-logs-project-install-gallery/325353-2016-ford-explorer-sport-build-log.html
 
Back
Top